Last reviewed: September 4, 2026.
Short version: Instapaper is best for simplicity, Readwise Reader for power users who take notes, Matter for newsletter reading on iPhone, and Textivore for former Pocket users who want full-text search and a complete data export.
Pocket itself is dead, so this is really a comparison of where Pocket users can go. The backstory on what happened to Pocket and Omnivore is in a separate post. I build Textivore, which makes me biased, so I've tried to be specific about where each of the other three beats it.
Quick verdict
| Instapaper | Readwise Reader | Matter | Textivore | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best for | Simplicity | Power users | Newsletter readers | Former Pocket users |
| Price/year | $59.99 | Paid only | Free core | $36 ($24 for the first 50) |
| Free tier | Unlimited saves | 30-day trial | Yes | 50 articles |
| Full-text search | Premium only | Yes | Limited | Yes |
| Pocket import | Yes | Yes | CSV only | Yes |
Pick Instapaper if you want the simplest experience. Pick Readwise Reader if you live in Obsidian or Notion and want every feature going. Matter is for people who mostly read newsletters on an iPhone, and Textivore is for people who want one-click Pocket import and a searchable reading library with no lock-in.
Instapaper, the original
Instapaper is free with unlimited saves. Premium is $59.99/year.
It has been around since 2008 and, together with Pocket, more or less defined the read-later category. It's still here, which counts for a lot. When Pocket shut down in 2025, Kobo chose Instapaper to replace it on its e-readers.
The text parsing is solid and handles most articles cleanly. Folders are easy to understand, there's a speed reading mode for skimming long pieces, and Kobo and Kindle integration lets you read on e-ink. The free tier is the most generous here: unlimited saves, and nothing held back to push you into paying.
Search is the weak spot. Full-text search needs Premium (the free tier only searches titles), and searching by tag also needs Premium even though both folders and tags exist. Development is slow and the app hasn't changed much in years. The browser extension works but looks dated, and highlighting and annotation are limited.
Instapaper is reliable and predictable. That's a real strength. But once you have hundreds of saved articles and need to find a specific one, missing search on the free tier becomes a real problem. I've been there: I knew I had saved an article, couldn't find it when I needed it, and stumbled on it months later.
Readwise Reader, the everything app
Readwise Reader needs a paid Readwise Full subscription, with a 30-day free trial.
Reader launched as a reading app for people who take notes seriously. Since then it has grown to handle articles, newsletters, RSS feeds, PDFs, YouTube transcripts, and Twitter threads.
It integrates deeply with Obsidian, Notion, Roam, and Logseq, and highlight syncing works across all of them. The built-in RSS reader can replace Feedly, there's a newsletter inbox for your subscriptions, and the AI features include summaries and Ghostreader. Full-text search covers everything.
The price is steep for something with no free tier beyond the trial. The interface can feel crowded, all those features make it slow on older devices, and setting up the integrations takes some learning. If you only want to save articles and read them later, it's overkill.
If your reading already feeds into a larger note system in Obsidian or Notion, Reader is hard to beat. If it doesn't, you're paying for a lot you won't use.
Matter, the newsletter reader
Matter's core features are free, and Premium is available on top.
Matter started as a social reading app and grew into a strong choice for people who read a lot of newsletters, especially on iOS. It offered displaced Pocket users 50% off, which I thought was a smart move.
Its text-to-speech is excellent for listening to articles. There's a built-in newsletter inbox, social highlights and discovery, and a clean, well designed iOS app. The free tier covers basic reading well.
There's no Android app, only iOS and the web, and the web app feels like an afterthought. Pocket import is CSV only, search is limited, and the browser extension is basic compared with the others. The team is smaller and new features arrive more slowly.
On an iPhone, for a heavy newsletter reader, Matter is excellent. Without Android and with a weak web app, though, it doesn't work for anyone who reads across several platforms.
Textivore, Pocket import plus a searchable library
Textivore is free for 50 saved articles, plus up to 500 imported links. Pro is $3.99/month or $36/year, and the first 50 founders pay $24/year.
I built Textivore around what Pocket users missed most: full-text search, clean reading, and keeping their data.
Full-text search covers everything you save, so you can find an article by what it said and not only by its title. Pocket import takes one click and keeps your tags. The reader view is clean, and the browser extension saves quickly. You can export everything as JSON at any time, and paid plans hold up to 10,000 articles.
It's a newer app, so the community is smaller and there are fewer integrations. There are no native mobile apps: it's a responsive web app, and saving from a phone goes through the Android share target or an iOS Shortcut. There's no highlight sync with external tools and no RSS reader or newsletter inbox, and the free tier is limited to 50 articles.
Search and Pocket import are where I think Textivore is strongest. It's younger than the others, which is why it has no native mobile apps or highlight sync yet. If you want your library searchable and exportable from the first day, it does that.
Feature comparison
| Feature | Instapaper | Readwise Reader | Matter | Textivore |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Price/year | $59.99 | Paid only | Free core | $36 ($24 for the first 50) |
| Free tier | Unlimited saves | 30-day trial | Yes | 50 articles |
| Full-text search | Premium only | Yes | Limited | Yes |
| Pocket import | Yes (keeps tags) | Yes | CSV only | Yes (preserves tags) |
| Browser extension | Yes | Yes | Basic | Yes |
| Mobile apps | iOS + Android | iOS + Android | iOS only | Web (responsive), Android share target, iOS Shortcut |
| E-reader support | Kobo + Kindle | Kindle | No | No |
| RSS/newsletters | No | Yes | Yes | No |
| Highlight sync | No | Obsidian, Notion, Roam | No | No |
| Data export | CSV | Markdown, CSV | Limited | JSON |
| Text-to-speech | No | Yes | Yes (HD) | No |
| Offline reading | Yes (mobile) | Yes (mobile) | Yes (mobile) | No |
| API access | Yes | Yes | No | No |
Which one fits how you read
You just want to save articles and read them
Pick Instapaper. It's simple and reliable, and it has the most generous free tier. You won't get full-text search, but if you read things soon after saving them, you may not miss it.
You take notes on everything you read
Pick Readwise Reader. Nothing else syncs highlights to Obsidian and Notion as well. It's expensive, but if note-taking is central to how you work, nothing else comes close.
You mostly read newsletters on an iPhone
Pick Matter. The newsletter inbox and text-to-speech are excellent for exactly this. You will be tied to Apple devices, though.
You used Pocket and want something similar
Pick Textivore. You get one-click Pocket import, full-text search, and the same save-and-read routine, in a reading library you own. Start free with 50 articles
You want the cheapest option
Pick Instapaper (free, unlimited) or Matter (free core features). Textivore's free tier stops at 50 articles, and Readwise has no free tier at all.
You read on a Kindle or Kobo
Pick Instapaper. Its e-reader integration is the best of the four, especially now that Kobo has officially partnered with it.
Tip
You don't have to pick just one. Plenty of people use Readwise Reader for deep research and a simpler app like Instapaper or Textivore for casual reading.
Can you trust the app to stay around?
Pocket had Mozilla and 35 million users. Omnivore was open source and had a community that loved it. Both shut down, and after that I weigh trust above features.
Start with the business model. Pocket and Omnivore were both free, and both disappeared. Then check whether you can get your data out in a standard format; if you can't, I'd walk away. Finally, look at the track record: how long the service has existed and whether anyone is still working on it.
Every app in this comparison lets you export your data, so export alone doesn't separate them anymore. The more useful question is whether the company has a sustainable way to pay for itself.
Frequently asked questions
Is Instapaper still free?
Yes. Instapaper offers unlimited free saves. The premium plan ($59.99/year) adds full-text search, highlights, and speed reading, but the free tier is perfectly usable on its own.
Which read-later app has full-text search?
Textivore and Readwise Reader both offer full-text search across all saved content. Instapaper only searches titles unless you pay for premium. Matter has limited search.
Can I import my Pocket library into another app?
Yes, if you have a Pocket export file. Textivore and Instapaper both support Pocket import. Both keep your Pocket tags. Textivore also keeps archive status and original save dates.
If you're still deciding, try your top two picks for a week each. Import a few articles, read in both, and keep the one you reach for. Developers can find API access, export, and technical content handling covered in the developer-focused comparison.
The features page lists what Textivore does, and you can import your Pocket library straight away if you have an export.
Start with 50 free articles